We're not kitten around: cats are nutty for our range of organic, made-in-USA catnip toys

Play

Well-made toys of joy for special occasions or any occasion!
81 products
  • Kong Naturals Crinkle Ball with Feathers Catnip Toy - Cat Supplies and More
    Sold out
    $4.39
  • Jewish Gelt Catnip Toy from Cat Supplies and More
    $4.29
    $4.29
  • Cat-a-Lack Rainbow Feather Ball 2-Pack
    Sold out
    $5.19
  • Cat'n Around Sam Snowman w/Catnip from Cat Supplies and More
    Sold out
    $5.95
  • Americana Patriotic Cat-Toys (2-Pack) from Cat Supplies and More
    Sold out
    $2.99
  • OurPet's Backyard Friend Bunny - Cat Supplies & More
    Sold out
    $4.59
  • Savvy Tabby 12-Piece Cat Toy Set - Cat Supplies & More
    $9.99
    $9.99
  • Da Bird Wand Toy Feather Refill from Cat Supplies and More
    $5.49
    $5.49
  • Vo-Toys Purrfectly Pink Long-Tailed Mouse
    $6.99
    $6.99
  • Play-n-Squeak Shake Y'r Tail Feather Cat Toy
    Sold out
    $6.99
  • Play-n-Squeak Raccoon Cat Toy
    Sold out
    $4.99
  • Christmas Rags to Riches Mice and Balls Cat Toys from Cat Supplies and More
    Sold out
    $4.49
  • Large
    $10.98
    $10.98
  • PetMate Crazy Circle Cat toy with refillable catnip ball to keep your cat fixated on chasing the ball
    $12.25
    $12.25
  • OurPet's Cosmic Catnip Hot Red Pepper Cat Toy from Cat Supplies & More
    $6.99
    $6.99